Compensatory Damages vs Punitive Damages

A serious accident can change your entire life in the course of a few moments. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that accidental injuries are responsible for 38 million emergency room trips each year. A personal injury claim is an important tool for justice because it allows you to seek compensation for your losses. The legal process is complicated. It is normal to have a lot of questions after an accident.

For example, you may be wondering: What is the difference between compensatory damages and punitive damages? The short answer is that compensatory damages are tied to the actual losses of the victims, whereas punitive damages punish the at-fault party. In this article, our Fort Lauderdale personal injury lawyer provides an in-depth guide to the most important things that you should know about the differences between compensatory damages and punitive damages in Florida.

What are Compensatory Damages in a Personal Injury Claim?

Are you considering suing for personal injury in Florida? A legal claim may be an option to get the financial support that you need to pay bills and move forward after a serious accident. In Florida, compensatory damages will generally make up the basis of your claim. Cornell Law School defines compensatory damages simply as “damages awarded by a court equivalent to the loss a party suffered.” In other words, compensatory damages are actual damages. They are linked to the losses—both economic and non-economic—that the victim suffered in the accident.

Types of Compensatory Damages

A serious accident can cause a wide range of different types of damages to a person and their family. All of the actual damages suffered by the victim can potentially fall under the larger umbrella term of “compensatory damages.” Here is an overview of the most common specific types of compensatory damages in Florida:

• Property Damage: Property damage refers to the monetary compensation provided to a plaintiff for damage or loss to their tangible property due to the defendant’s negligence or intentional misconduct. For example, in an auto accident case, the cost of repairing or replacing the damaged vehicle would constitute property damage. Indeed, a typical car accident settlement amount will generally include compensation for property damage.

• Medical Bills: Medical expenses are a type of compensatory damage intended to cover the cost of medical treatment necessitated by the defendant’s actions. It includes expenses for hospital stays, surgeries, medications, physical therapy, and any future medical costs related to the injury. Documentation such as receipts and doctor’s reports are often required to substantiate these claims.

• Lost Wages: If an injured party misses work due to their injury, they may be compensated for their lost wages. This not only covers the period they were unable to work but may also extend to future earning potential if their ability to work has been diminished or eliminated by the injury.

• Pain and Suffering: Pain and suffering is a non-economic damage—but it still falls into the broader category of compensatory damages. It is a type of compensation meant to account for the physical pain and emotional distress suffered by the plaintiff as a result of the defendant’s actions. It can be difficult to quantify as it depends on subjective experiences, but factors such as the severity and duration of pain, the nature of the injury, and the disruption to the plaintiff’s life are often considered.
• Disability/Disfigurement: This category of damages compensates for the life-altering effects of an injury that results in a disability or physical disfigurement. It aims to address both economic losses (like the loss of earning capacity) and non-economic losses (such as the psychological impact of living with a disability or disfigurement). The compensation amount usually considers the permanence and severity of the disability or disfigurement.

What are Punitive Damages in a Personal Injury Claim?

The Legal Information Institute defines punitive damages as a type of damages that are “considered punishment and are typically awarded at the court’s discretion when the defendant’s behavior is found to be especially harmful.” In other words, punitive damages are not tied directly to a specific “loss” sustained by the victim or their family. Instead, punitive damages are meant to serve as an example. They are designed to help ensure that other parties do not engage in similar, especially harmful conduct as the defendant. To be clear, punitive damages are still awarded to the victim. Note: Punitive damages are only granted in a very small share of personal injury claims in Florida.

888-530-1212

Understanding the Differences Between Compensatory and Punitive Damages

Compensatory and punitive damages serve distinct purposes in the civil law system, and understanding their differences is key when assessing a personal injury claim in Florida. Here are four of the most important differences between compensatory damages and punitive damages:

• The Purpose (Intent): Compensatory damages aim to make the injured party whole again by financially covering their losses, including property damage, medical bills, and lost wages. In contrast, punitive damages are designed to punish the defendant for particularly reckless or malicious behavior and deter others from engaging in similar conduct.
• The Calculation (Value of Damages): Compensatory damages are calculated based on the actual losses suffered by the plaintiff, quantifiable through bills, receipts, and wage statements. Punitive damages, however, are not linked to the plaintiff’s actual damages but are determined based on the severity of the defendant’s misconduct and their financial status, as the intention is to inflict financial pain as punishment.
• Occurrence (Punitive Damages are Rare): While compensatory damages are common in most personal injury cases, punitive damages are less frequently awarded. They are usually reserved for cases where the defendant’s behavior was outrageously negligent, reckless, or malicious.
• Taxation (Punitive Taxable): In the United States, compensatory damages are typically tax-free unless they compensate for a loss that was previously used as a tax deduction. On the other hand, punitive damages are generally taxable.

How are Punitive Damages Calculated?

It depends on a wide range of different factors. Punitive damages are not calculated based on the actual damages or losses suffered by the plaintiff, but rather, they are determined by the severity of the defendant’s misconduct and the defendant’s financial status. The intent is to punish and deter, so the punitive award must be substantial enough to impact the defendant financially. Courts often consider factors such as the reprehensibility of the defendant’s conduct, the harm caused, and how much money would sufficiently deter the defendant or similar parties in the future.

Are Punitive Damages Worth More Than Compensatory Damages?

They certainly can be—but it is a highly case-specific matter. Under Florida law, punitive damages can exceed the amount of compensatory damages. That being said, the United States Supreme Court has suggested that punitive damages awards exceeding a single-digit ratio to compensatory damages might be constitutionally suspect. In other words, a punitive damages award that is ten times the compensatory damages or higher may raise due process concerns. If you have specific questions about the value of your case, an experienced Fort Lauderdale car accident lawyer can help.

To learn more, schedule a free consultation with us today.

Free Case Evaluation

Can Punitive Damages Be Awarded Without Compensatory Damages?

Typically, punitive damages are awarded in addition to compensatory damages and not in isolation. The reason is that punitive damages are meant to punish the defendant for conduct that has caused actual harm, which is usually evidenced by an award of compensatory damages. Still, it is important to understand that every case is unique. There could be a situation in which an injured victim in Florida is entitled to relatively limited compensatory damages but could be entitled to substantial punitive damages. You should always consult with a top Florida personal injury lawyer.

Your Guide to Taxation and Compensatory/Punitive Damages

Taxes matter. The taxation of damages awarded in a lawsuit can be a complex issue—and it is often influenced by the specific circumstances of the case. However, in general, there are significant tax differences between compensatory and punitive damages in the United States, including in Florida. Here is an overview of the tax differences:

• Compensatory Damages: Compensatory damages are intended to restore the plaintiff to the financial state they would have been in had the injury or harm not occurred. This can cover a wide range of economic losses, including medical expenses, lost wages, and property damage. As a general rule, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) does not tax compensatory damages that arise from personal physical injuries or physical sickness. This is because the IRS views these damages as a restoration of capital, not as income. However, there are some exceptions that apply. A case-by-case assessment is crucial.
• Punitive Damages: In contrast, punitive damages are intended to punish the defendant for egregious behavior and deter similar conduct in the future. Unlike compensatory damages, punitive damages are considered income. As such, they are generally taxable under U.S. law—even if they are associated with a physical or non-physical injury. Punitive damages are considered an addition to the taxpayer’s wealth, not simply a restoration of losses.

Categories of Damages/Costs That are Not Punitive Damages

As noted, punitive damages are a limited type of damages that are awarded to the victim in order to punish the especially harmful actions or inactions of the at-fault party. Here are three key categories of damages that are not considered to be punitive damages in Florida:

• Pain and Suffering: Following an accident, you may want to sue for pain and suffering. Pain and suffering are non-economic damages. It is compensatory damage. It is a real loss suffered by the victim that deserves compensation.

• Emotional Distress: Similar to pain and suffering, emotional distress is non-economic damage that is considered to be compensatory in nature. It is actual harm suffered by the victim.

• Attorneys’ Fees: Attorneys’ fees are not part of punitive damages. You can hire a Florida personal injury lawyer to handle your claim on contingency, meaning you will not be required to pay out of your own pocket.

Hire BK Law to Help Secure More Damages in Your Case

Personal injury claims are complicated. Most people have a lot of questions after a serious accident—from issues related to the statute of limitations in a personal injury lawsuit to concerns about the amount of financial compensation that can be recovered in an accident. Reach out today before the deadline for filing an injury lawsuit has passed. At BK Law, we are strong advocates for real justice. Our attorneys are always prepared to go above and beyond to ensure that your claim is handled the right way. At Bernheim Kelley Battista, LLC, our Florida personal injury attorneys have the professional expertise that you can trust. If you or your loved one was hurt in an accident and you have questions about compensatory damages and/or punitive damages, we are here to help. Contact us today for a free, no-obligation consultation. With an office in Fort Lauderdale and other offices throughout the region, we fight for the rights and interests of injured victims across Florida.