Search
English | Español
Bernheim Kelley Personal Injury Lawyers
Call
Menu

A background check error can cost you a job you were counting on. Whether an employer withdraws an offer or stops responding to you, losing an opportunity because of inaccurate information can affect your income, your career, and your peace of mind.

Fortunately, there are protections in place. If a background check error costs you a job, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) gives you options for disputing the report and seeking compensation. Employers also must follow specific notice requirements before they can reject you.

Here, we cover what kinds of errors show up, what employers are required to do before saying no, how to dispute a bad report, and when a lawsuit may be an option.

If you believe you have an FCRA claim, speak with an experienced Florida FCRA attorney.


The Real Deal: A Background Check Error Can Cost You a Real Opportunity


What Kinds of Background Check Errors Can Cost Me a Job?

One of the more damaging types of errors is a mixed file. This is when a screening company mistakenly attaches someone else’s criminal record to your name because of a common name, a missing middle name, or a sloppy match. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) found that one major screener didn’t even require employers to supply applicants’ middle names.

Other common problems the CFPB identified include:

The FCRA also limits how long certain negative information can appear on a background check, generally to 7 years, although exceptions apply. That could include arrest records, civil suits, and judgments (convictions are an exception and can generally be reported indefinitely). However, the 7-year restriction doesn’t apply to jobs expected to pay $75,000 or more (15 U.S. Code § 1681c(b)(3)).

In Florida, eligible people can seal or expunge certain records through the court system, and sealed or expunged records aren’t public. However, the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) notes that it has no authority over private data companies, so an old record can still surface on a commercial background check after it’s been sealed.

If a sealed or expunged record appears on a commercial background check, the FCRA may provide a way to challenge how that information was reported.


What Does the FCRA Require Before an Employer Can Deny Me a Job?

When an employer uses a background check prepared by a third-party screening company, the FCRA doesn’t let it simply read the report and say no. It lays out three required steps, including protections that give you a chance to catch an error before it costs you the job.

The three steps a Florida employer must follow:

  1. Disclosure & Authorization: Before running the check, the employer has to tell you in a clear, stand-alone written document that it may use a consumer report for employment decisions, and get your written permission. That disclosure can’t be buried in the job application.
  2. Pre-Adverse Action Notice: If the employer plans to reject you, rescind an offer, or pass you over based on the report, it must first give you a copy of the report and the document “A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.” In the FTC’s words, this gives job applicants “the opportunity to review the report and tell you if it is correct.”
  3. Adverse Action Notice: After the final decision, the employer must tell you the screening company’s name, address, and phone number; state that the screening company didn’t make the decision; and notify you of your right to dispute the report and get a free copy within 60 days. 

These rules apply even if the background check is accurate. If an employer fails to give you the required notices or gets your report without permission, it may have violated the FCRA.


What Should I Do if the Background Check Is Wrong?

Acting quickly is important, both because the employer may still be deciding and because the FCRA’s deadlines run from when you discover the violation. 

The CFPB and FTC both recommend asking the employer for the screening company’s name at the time you consent, so you know exactly who to contact if something goes wrong.

Steps to take as soon as you spot an error:

For a Florida criminal-record error, you can also request a free Personal Review of your own FDLE record to confirm what the state actually has on file, and challenge inaccuracies with FDLE (Florida Statutes § 943.056(1)).

Complaints can go to the Florida Attorney General at 1-866-9-NO-SCAM, the CFPB, or the FTC. But please understand, a complaint is separate from, and doesn’t replace, a legal claim.


Can I Sue Over an Employment Background Check Error?

Yes, the FCRA gives job applicants a private right to sue. What you can recover depends on whether the violation was “negligent” or “willful.”

A negligent violation is when a company fails to use reasonable care to follow the law. A willful violation is when they knowingly break the law or recklessly disregard it.

Potential defendants include:

  1. The screening company that failed to use reasonable processes for accuracy
  2. The employer that failed to follow the required notice steps

The FCRA provides different types of compensation depending on the violation:

Actual damages can be significant and can include lost wages, the difference in pay from a job you had to take instead, and emotional distress. But every case depends on its own facts, and no outcome is guaranteed.

Timing matters as well: an FCRA claim must be filed within 2 years of when you discovered the violation, or 5 years from when it happened, whichever comes first (15 U.S.C. § 1681p).


Should I Talk to an FCRA Lawyer?

FCRA cases often hinge on details that are easy to miss without experience, such as:

An attorney can identify violations you may not know to look for.

Because the FCRA allows recovery of attorney’s fees in successful cases, firms like Bernheim Kelley handle these consumer protection cases without charging attorney’s fees or costs, regardless of whether the case is successful. If we’re able to recover compensation, that money goes to you. That makes it a lot easier for you to take on a national screening company.

An early consultation also helps you avoid mistakes that can weaken a claim, like missing the 2-year deadline or failing to document the problem properly.


Real Action: Call the FCRA Attorneys at Bernheim Kelley

Losing a job over a background check error affects your income, your family, and your sense of dignity. At Bernheim Kelley, we are Real Advocates who treat it that way. Our FCRA attorneys help Florida workers review their reports, identify who’s responsible, dispute inaccuracies, and pursue the compensation the law allows. 

And we do all this at no cost to you. To request your FREE case review, call 954-329-0440 today.

Call for your
Free Consultation!